| 1886-1964 | Thomas Wood | 1964-1997 | Otto Lewis |
| Joe Dorrell | 1997-1998 | Gene Pettijohn | |
| John Barmun | 1998-2003 | Louis Phillips | |
| Frankl Wilkins | January 2003-November 2003 (interim) | Chris Mattison | |
| Jake Wright | November 2003-February 2005 | Joe Pitcher | |
| Samuel Benefield | February 2005-June 2005 (interim) | Jason Davis | |
| J.B. White | June 2005-March 2012 | Gary Neeman | |
| George Horner | March 2012-May 2012 (interim) | Dave Lowe | |
| N.R. Tracy | May 2012-August 2025 | Ricky Shipp | |
| Tom Carson | August 2025-October 2025 | Kenneth Polley Jr | |
| Leonard Yaste | October 2025-Present | Derek Cox | |
| W.D. Brown | |||
| Abner Carson | |||
| W.L. Perkins | |||
| Wash Draper | |||
| P. T. Brown | |||
| Chester Brewer | |||
| John Collins | |||
| Rolla Ditmars | |||
| Jess Bennett | |||
| Clyde Shephard | |||
| Frank Rice | |||
| Otis Tearman | |||
| James Lambert | |||
| Andy Stillabower | |||
| Walter Thomas | |||
| Murl Allen | |||
| Charles Tearman | |||
| Dick Wood |
The Whiteland Police Department exists to serve our community in a variety of ways and to maintain acceptable social order. Specifically, our purpose is to encourage a spirit of cooperation, respect, fairness and compassion within the community.
We are committed to provide our Town with community-oriented law enforcement to protect life and property, by providing a “commitment to excellence” to the citizens and visitors of Whiteland.
The members of the Whiteland Police Department are dedicated to providing the highest quality police services in order to enhance community safety, protect life & property, and to reduce crime & the fear of crime.
To the end, we pledge to develop a partnership with the community, lead a community, commitment to resolve problems, improve the safety & quality of life in our town by identifying and resolving public safety concerns. We further pledge to build and maintain the public trust by holding ourselves to the highest standards of professionalism in our job performance and ethics.
The Town Council has set a policy, through the
adoption of the Department Mission Statement;
mandating community based policing, specifically
with a “hometown” atmosphere in mind.
Further, due to the limited number of Town
employees, our officers are occasionally called
upon to handle situations that may not typically
fall within the purview of urban police officers. However, this is the “policing atmosphere” our citizens expect from our Police Department. Thus, we strive to truly be a full service agency.
Lt. Derek Cox named new Whiteland police chief
October 1, 2025 By Elissa Maudlin (https://dailyjournal.net/author/emaudlin/)
In what was referred to as a “difficult” decision, a new police chief has been named for the town of Whiteland.
Lt. Derek Cox was unanimously named Whiteland’s new town marshal, more commonly known as police chief, at a special town council meeting on Tuesday. He will be taking the reins after the previous police chief, Rick Shipp, retired at the start of August and Sgt. Kenneth Polley Jr. served as interim police chief.
Cox, 47 of Whiteland, has worked for the Whiteland Police Department for almost 22 years. He started as a reserve officer and was hired full-time approximately a year and a half later. He has been moving his way up through the department since.
He has worked in public safety in Johnson County since approximately 2000. Cox’s experience also includes working for the sheriff’s office and juvenile detention center, he said.
Now head of Whiteland’s police department, Cox is filling the shoes of Shipp, who served in the department for 17 years, became chief in 2012, and had spent over 40 years in law enforcement.
“It’s everything that I’ve worked towards in my entire career, and I couldn’t be happier,” Cox said of his new position. “Couldn’t be in a better place, couldn’t have better people to work with.”
Cox decided he wanted to take on the role of chief as he started leading and running parts of the department in other roles. His first goals as chief are to get his team together, communicate effectively and get started, he said.
“I couldn’t be happier to be here and look forward to serving the community, as I have for half my life now,” Cox said.
The hiring decision wasn’t easy for the town council, council president Richard Hill and council member Tim Brown said at the meeting.
“You folks made a very difficult decision for us,” Hill said. “We did our proper vetting, due diligence, and I think we’ve come to a reasonable conclusion.”
During council remarks, Brown referenced a letter that members of the police department gave to the council about the hiring decision. The letter was written by police officers to encourage the council to consider and prioritize internal candidates, according to Julia Meece, the department’s administrative assistant.
“We believe that continuing to grow our leadership from within will not only boost morale but also inspire the next generation of officers to work with integrity and purpose,’” Meece said, reading an excerpt of a letter. “‘This is a pivotal time for our department and we ask that you give strong consideration to those who have long served this town and understand its needs and values intimately.’”
Meece said there were, to her knowledge, about eight applicants, with two of them being internal.
Brown thanked the police department for the letter, saying it “pulled a lot of weight” with the council.
“This is one of the hardest decisions I’ve had to make on this council,” Brown said. “I know I’m not going to make everybody happy, and I know I’m going to make some people mad, but I have to do what I think is best in my decision. I just want you to know I do appreciate all the work that you guys do for us, I really do.”
Council member Joe Sayler said Tuesday that multiple candidates were close friends of his. He thanked Polley for his service as interim police chief, and, like other council members, Sayler thought the decision was “really, really, really difficult” to make.
Council vice president Deb Hendrickson added that she is glad the council had multiple good candidates to choose from.
While council member Brad Goedeker said he was “very excited” and thanked the officers and others who gave input.
Cox will start as police chief a week from Tuesday to ensure that the appropriate transition and communication can happen, Goedeker said
1
2
Richard Hill, President Brad Goedeker Joe Saylor
Debra Hendrickson, Vice President Tim Brown
The Whiteland Police Department has evolved from a one-man full time force with on-call Reserve Officers in 1996 to the thirteen full-time Officers & two Reserve Officers force that exists today.
Lifesaving Award
2024: Brian Smith
2023: Matthew Kegeris, Jeremy McKinney, Emily Vautaw, & Brian Webb
2022: Kenny Polley and Chris Wilcher
2017: Jared Donica
2016: Brian Smith and Chris Speer
2015: Derek Cox and Tyler Croy
Otto Lewis Outstanding Law Enforcement Officer of the Year Award
2024: Andy Mitchell 2019: Derek Cox
2023: Kenny Polley 2018: Brian Smith
2022: Chris Wilcher 2017: Todd Pershing
2021: Brian Webb 2016: Rick Shipp
2020: Scott Doss and Vader 2015: Tyler Croy
Whiteland Police Department Employee MVP Award
2023: Julia Meece 2022: Julia Meece
Whiteland Police Department Employee of the Year Award
2016: Roberta Groves
WPD Years of Service Pins
5 Years: Andy Mitchell, Kenny Polley, Scott Doss, Todd Pershing
10 Years: Brian Webb, Brian Smith, Tyler Croy
15 Years: Rick Shipp
20 Years: Derek Cox
14
One Chief of Police One Operations Administrative Two Reserve Officers
Two Lieutenants Specialist (ten authorized by ordinance)
Two Sergeants
Eight Police Officers
One Canine